Insurance

Cold Calling for Insurance Agents: How It Works and Cost

Cold calling for insurance means a dedicated caller works your aged or fresh lists, qualifies the prospect, and books the appointment so your licensed agent quotes and closes. Managed plans run a flat monthly rate per caller, not a per-lead fee, and bundle the dialer, QA, DNC scrubbing, and CRM into the price. The value is in keeping licensed agents on quoting instead of dialing.

What does cold calling for insurance involve?

A dedicated caller dials your aged or fresh lists across final expense, Medicare, life, or P&C, qualifies the prospect, and books the appointment onto your agent calendar. The licensed agent does the quoting and closing, the caller handles the dialing, qualifying, and scheduling. See how our insurance appointment setting works.

What does it cost?

Managed cold calling for insurance runs a flat monthly rate per dedicated caller, not a price per lead. Call Savvys plans run $1,200 to $3,300 per month, all in, including the caller, the dialer, AI-plus-human QA, DNC-scrubbed lists, and the free Pipelio CRM. Data is the one add-on, dial your own aged leads, or we pull and skip-trace a fresh list at $0.03 per record.

$1,200to $3,300 per month per dedicated caller, all in, with data at $0.03 per record or bring your own

How does that compare to buying leads or live transfers?

Buying leads or live transfers is priced per unit, and those leads are often shared with several agencies. A dedicated caller is a flat monthly rate working your exclusive lists all month, with a written guarantee. Both models exist for a reason, but calling gives you exclusivity and control that shared leads do not. See live transfers vs appointments.

What do you get for the price?

A dedicated caller working your lists every business day, with qualified appointments booked for your agents, not a shared pool. Every dedicated caller is guaranteed 10 to 20 qualified insurance leads a month, in writing, with AI scoring and human QA on every call, DNC-scrubbed lists, and a 24-hour replacement if a caller is not the right fit. See pricing.

10 to 20qualified insurance leads per dedicated caller per month, guaranteed in writing

Frequently asked questions

Managed plans typically run $1,200 to $3,300 per month per dedicated caller, all in, including the dialer, QA, DNC-scrubbed lists, and free CRM. Data is the add-on, either dial your own aged leads or have a fresh list pulled and skip-traced at $0.03 per record.
No, appointment-setting callers dial, qualify, and book the prospect, then hand the appointment to your licensed agent to quote and close. This keeps your licensed producers focused on selling rather than dialing.
Austin Rice
Austin Rice
Cofounder, Call Savvys

Austin Rice cofounded Call Savvys in 2022. His team places 10,000+ cold calls a day for 400+ real estate operators, so the playbooks here come from live campaigns, not theory.

Keep reading

Want this handled for you?

Book your free strategy call and we will map exactly how many leads we can generate in your market.

Book my free strategy call

Book your free strategy call

Free 30-minute call. No obligation, cancel anytime.

10 to 20 qualified insurance leads per caller, guaranteed in writing.

What best describes you?

Book my free strategy call